It is no exaggeration to say that antibiotics make
modern medicine possible. Complex medical
interventions like organ transplants, hip
replacements and even chemotherapy are all made
possible or better by the use of antibiotics. And
rightly so, major diseases like syphilis, gonorrhoea,
leprosy, and tuberculosis, have lost much of their
sting. But antibiotics lose their effectiveness over time as bacteria naturally evolve and mutate and so
become resistant. The world is on the brink of losing
these miracle cures. Even World Health Organisation
(WHO) has selected “combating antimicrobial
resistance” as the theme for World Health Day 2011.
We seem to have come a full circle from the preantibiotic
phase through a successful phase of
infection control to a seemingly frightening postantibiotic
era of multidrug resistant bacteria
desperate for the elusive magic bullet.
Resistance in microorganisms is defined as their
unresponsiveness to the standard doses of drugs.
The development of resistance is a natural
biological process that will occur, sooner or later,
with every drug. However, irrational use of
antimicrobial agents, faulty practices and flawed
assumptions has clearly made the inevitable
development of drug resistance happen much
sooner, rather than later.
Resistance is not a new phenomenon; it was
recognised early as a scientific curiosity and then as a threat to effective treatment outcome.
Antimicrobial resistance is one of the biggest
challenges to face global public health at the
beginning of the third millennium. Ever since
antibiotics became widely available in the 1940s,
they have been hailed as miracle drugs- magic
bullets able to eliminate bacteria without doing
much harm to the cells of treated individuals. Yet
with each passing decade, bacteria that defy not
only single but multiple antibiotics, and therefore
are extremely difficult to control, have become
increasingly common. After more than 50 years,
however, widespread use of antibiotics is thought to
have spurred evolutionary adaptations that enable
bacteria to survive these powerful drugs.
Antimicrobial resistance provides a survival benefit
to microbes and makes it harder to eliminate
infections from the body. Antibiotic resistance has
become a serious public health concern with
economic and social implications throughout the
world, be it community acquired infections like
streptococcal infections, pneumonia, typhoid fever,
etc., or hospital acquired infections due to
methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus
(MRSA),vancomycin resistant enterococci (VRE),
vancomycin intermediate S. aureus (VISA) or
extended spectrum beta-lactamase (ESBL) enzyme
producing Gram negative bacteria. However,
developing countries are hit hard with increasing
reports of development of resistance to drugs
commonly used to treat most of the communicable
diseases. The emerging threat of resistance in malaria, tuberculosis (TB) and human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection is a huge
impediment in achieving the Millennium
Development Goals (MDGs) by 2015. Infections
caused by resistant microorganisms often fail to
respond to conventional treatment, resulting in
prolonged illness and greater risk of death.
Antibiotic-resistant pathogens are not more virulent
than susceptible ones: the same numbers of
resistant and susceptible bacterial cells are
required to produce disease. The looming threat of
incurable Staphylococcus aureus is just the latest twist in an international public health nightmare:
Worldwide, many strains of Staphylococcus aureus
are already resistant to all antibiotics except
vancomycin. Emergence of forms lacking sensitivity
to vancomycin signifies that variants untreatable by
every known antibiotic are on their way. Resistance
to first-line anti-TB drugs has become a concern for
national TB control programmes. It is estimated that
around 180,000 cases of MDR-TB reside/occur
annually in the south east Asian region with more
than 80 per cent of these being in Bangladesh, India,
Indonesia, Myanmar and Thailand. Although the
generic antiretroviral (ART) drugs available in this
region are contributing greatly towards improving
the survival rate of patients worldwide and in rendering HIV as a chronic but a manageable
condition, there are reports of the emergence of
resistance that is a serious cause of concern. There
has been a substantial change in the antimicrobial
susceptibility of Neisseria gonorrhoeae. Resistant
malaria has already become a major issue for a
population of 400 million living in areas that expose them to a high risk of contracting it. Multidrug
resistant Klebsiella, Pseudomonas and
Acinetobacter species have given new dimensions to
the problem of hospital-associated infections [1].
How did we end up in this worrisome, and
worsening, situation?
Several interacting processes are at fault. One
component of the solution is recognising that
bacteria are a natural, and needed, part of life.
People should realise that although antibiotics are
needed to control bacterial infections, they can
have broad, undesirable effects on microbial
ecology not only in the treated individual but also in
the environment and society at large. Although
many factors can influence whether bacteria in a person or in a community will become insensitive to
an antibiotic, the two main forces are the
prevalence of resistance genes (which give rise to
proteins that shield bacteria from an antibiotic's
effects) and the extent of antibiotic use. And
frequently, bacteria will gain a defense against an
antibiotic by taking up resistance genes from other
bacterial cells in the vicinity. Indeed, the exchange
of genes is so pervasive that the entire bacterial
world can be thought of as one huge multicellular
organism in which the cells interchange their genes
with ease. In a regrettable twist of fate for human beings, many bacteria play host to specialised transposons, termed integrons that are like flypaper
in their propensity for capturing new genes. These
integrons can consist of several different resistance
genes, which are passed to other bacteria as whole regiments of antibiotic-defying guerrillas.
How antibiotics promote resistance?
The selection process is fairly straightforward.
When an antibiotic attacks a group of bacteria, cells
that are highly susceptible to the medicine will die.
But cells that have some resistance from the start,
or that acquire it later (through mutation or gene
exchange), may survive, especially if too little drug
is given to overwhelm the cells that are present.
Those cells, facing reduced competition from
susceptible bacteria, will then go on to proliferate.
When confronted with an antibiotic, the most
resistant cells in a group will inevitably outcompete
all others. Promoting resistance in known pathogens
is not the only self-defeating activity of antibiotics.
When the medicines attack disease-causing
bacteria, they also affect benign bacteria--innocent
bystanders-in their path. They eliminate drugsusceptible
bystanders that could otherwise limit
the expansion of pathogens, and they
simultaneously encourage the growth of resistant
bystanders. Propagation of these resistant,
nonpathogenic bacteria increases the reservoir of
resistance traits in the bacterial population as a
whole and raises the odds that such traits will spread
to pathogens. In addition, sometimes the growing
populations of bystanders themselves become
agents of disease. Widespread use of cephalosporin
antibiotics, for example, has promoted the
proliferation of the once benign intestinal
bacterium Enterococcus faecalis, which is naturally
resistant to those drugs. The ever increasing volume
of international travel has hastened transfer of
antibiotic resistance, that emerges in one place can
often spread far and wide [2]. Researchers at the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have
estimated that some 50 million of the 150 million
outpatient prescriptions for antibiotics every year
are unneeded. In the developing world, antibiotic
use is even less controlled. Many of the same drugs
marketed in the industrial nations are available over
the counter. Unfortunately, when resistance becomes a clinical problem, those countries, which
often do not have access to expensive drugs, may
have no substitutes available.
The growing challenge of antimicrobial resistance– need to comtemplate!
It is clear that bacteria will continue to develop
resistance to currently available antibacterial drugs
by either new mutations or the exchange of genetic
information. Absence of appropriate legislation or
its enforcement may result in the proliferation
where untrained or poorly trained persons dispense
antimicrobials, leading to overuse and
inappropriate use. Using the appropriate drug at the
appropriate dosage and for the appropriate
duration is one important means of reducing the
selective pressure that helps resistant organisms
emerge. If an infection is addressed in a
comprehensive and timely manner, resistance can
be contained. Optimal use of existing antimicrobial
agents, using alternative treatment options (where
possible), reducing the need for antimicrobials by
increasing immunity, reducing the use of
antimicrobials without providing an alternative
form of treatment through education of health
professionals and patients, antibiotic policies
implementation of infection control measures (e.g.,
hand washing, screening and isolation) are the
strategies aimed at prevention of emergence and
spread of antibiotic resistance. Advertising and
promotion can also be used to improve the
appropriate use of antibiotics. Microbiologic
culture-based or targeted antibiotic therapy is an
important factor in decreasing inappropriate
antibiotic usage. Using the most cost-effective
antibiotic with the least resistance-inducing
capacity, combination therapies and vaccination are
of critical importance.
Historically, several approaches to antibiotic
prescribing have been employed to address
antimicrobial resistance. One approach is to use a
newer more potent antimicrobial in settings where
resistance has emerged to an older agent. Another
approach to combating resistance is to continue
using older agents as first line choices, in preference
to newer, more potent drugs, in an effort to
preserve the activity of the new drugs. Efforts to
overcome bacterial resistance range from judicious
and rationale use of antibiotics, effective hospital
infection control programme and research in the field related to development of newer antibiotics. The use of antibiotics in the community can be
restricted by implementing laws to stop over the
counter sale of antibiotics. Another approach is to
use a combination therapy.
On World Health Day 2011, WHO is urging intensified
global commitment to safeguard antibiotics for
preventing and controlling infectious diseases as
well as for future generations. Growing resistance in
microbes to antibiotics threatens the continued
effectiveness of many medicines. WHO has
therefore made antimicrobial resistance the theme
of this year’s World Health Day. The WHO defines
appropriate use of antibiotics as “the cost-effective
use of antibiotics, which maximises clinical
therapeutic effect while minimising both drugrelated
toxicity and the development of antibiotic
resistance” [3]. “No action today means no cure
tomorrow”. At a time of multiple calamities in the
world, we cannot allow the loss of essential
medicines – essential cures for many millions of
people – to become the next global crisis. On this World Health Day, WHO is issuing a policy
package to get everyone, especially governments
and their drug regulatory systems, on the right
track, with the right measures, quickly-
- Promote national coordination.
- Strengthen the surveillance of antibiotic
resistance.
- Promote the rational use of antibiotics,
including surveillance of antibiotic consumption.
- Improve infection control and the stewardship of antibiotic use in health care settings.
- Promote the surveillance, prevention and control of antibiotic resistance in the food chain.
- Promote research and innovation on new antibiotics.
- Improve awareness on antibiotic use and the risk of increasing resistance.
How healthcare providers can help?
Healthcare providers can address antimicrobial
resistance and have a tremendous impact on
protecting patients. There are several steps
healthcare providers can take to prevent drugresistant
germs from infecting their patients or being spread in their healthcare facilities.
- Ensure prompt diagnosis of antimicrobialresistant
infections.
- Provide appropriate and early treatment.
- Be a good steward of antimicrobials.
- Make sure all orders have a dose,
duration, and indication.
- Include laboratory cultures when placing
an order.
- Take an "antimicrobial time out", reassessing
therapy after 48-72 hours.
- Prevention is the key.
Conflict of interest: None declared.
Source of funding: Nil.
References
-
Arias CA. Murray BE. Antibiotic resistant bugs in the 21st century - A clinical superchallenge.
N Engl J Med 2009:360:439-42.
- MacPherson DW, Gushulak BD, Baine WB, Bala
S, Gubbins 8. PO, Holtom P, et al. Population
mobility, globalization and antimicrobial drug
resistance. Emerg Infect Dis 2009;15:1727-32.
- World Health Organization. WHO Global
Strategy for Containment of Antimicrobial
Resistance. Geneva: WHO, 2001. Available at:
http://www.who.int/entity/csr/resources/publications/drugresist/en/EGlobal_Strat.pd,
Accessed on May 5, 2010.